History
>
GCSE
>
America 1789 -1900
>
Why did th...
2 years ago
·
5 Replies
·
703 views
Aubrey
5 Answers
Experienced online tutor. Average value added of 1.5 grades
7 reviews
Lincoln in fact didn't make the war about slavery from 1861. On the contrary, he was willing to sign a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the continued existence of slavery where it was already happening. In 1861 his response was about armed rebellion against the government. It was the Confederacy that effectively made the war about slavery by refusing to accept the draft constitutional amendment as a compromise.
If you mean the Emancipation Proclamation of 1863: First of all, he needed to give the north a big moral/morale lift after two years where they thought they weren't getting very far. Making it a moral crusade meant the North would be much more willing to fight the long, costly war needed to overcome the Confederacy.
Second, it would make it much less likely the British or French would diplomatically support the south, which was needed as Britain in particular was being rather slack about enforcing trade embargoes - they had even sold 18 warships to the South.
Third, it raised the possibility the slaves in the south - note that the Emancipation Proclamation didn't apply to the slaves in Kentucky or Delaware which were in the North - might rise in rebellion. As it happens that didn't occur, although some slaves did actively claim their freedom e.g. Robert Smalls who sailed his boat out to the Union blockade. It also helpfully sorted out what to do with any slaves who were taken prisoner by the Union - they were just declared to be free and allowed to enlist.
But again, mostly it simply reiterated what had caused the crisis - the existence of slavery, the determination of wealthy southerners to preserve it against the determination of Northerners to get rid of it. Lincoln was opposed to slavery, getting rid of it was the whole reason why the Republican party was founded, and helpfully from his point of view the longer the war went on the more northern people came to dislike both the south in general and slavery in particular for causing it, and saw getting rid of slavery as the best reason for winning the war. So the Emancipation Proclamation actually followed public opinion on this.
I'm available for 1:1 private online tuition!
Click here to view my profile and arrange a free introduction.Experienced and Fun GCSE Humanities Tutor
6 reviews
Lincoln made the war about slavery as he wished for more black men to take part in the war as soldiers, some would argue that he had ulterior motives in the emancipation as he required more soldiers.
I'm available for 1:1 private online tuition!
Click here to view my profile and arrange a free introduction.Firstly, because he was an abolitionist and a believed slavery was immoral. However, perhaps more importantly in terms of Lincolns decision-making, is that it facilitated the mass mobilisation of African-Americans into the Union Army. Moreover, it also meant that the UK, who were a large importer of Southern (Confederate) goods, were far less likely to join the war in favour of the confederates.
Hi Aubrey, the answer to this question is that although Lincoln was personally against Slavery, he felt as though he could not not bring his personal beliefs into his presidency without a reason and so he used the war as a way to get this view across.
Lincoln made the Civil War about slavery to redefine the conflict's purpose and unify the North against the South. By framing the war as a fight for freedom and equality, he aimed to bolster support for the Union cause and undermine the Confederacy's economic foundation, which relied heavily on slavery. This shift helped galvanize public sentiment but also paved the way for the Emancipation Proclamation, which declared the freedom of enslaved people in Confederate-held territories.
Think you can help?
Get started with a free online introductions with an experienced and qualified online tutor on Sherpa.
Find a GCSE History Tutor