GUEST POST
Beth is a GCSE Geography and A-Level Geography tutor and qualified teacher who has marked AQA GCSE Geography for six years. This article explains how specific place-based evidence can lift Geography answers to higher levels, what mark schemes expect, and ways to remember case-study details.
By Beth | GCSE and A-Level Geography Tutor | Sherpa Tutor
Knowing the content of the subject is extremely important for your exams. It helps you answer questions and expand on your explanations fully. Is your content excellent but you're still not getting full marks? That's where evidence comes in. This article will explore how using evidence to support your answers helps you achieve the highest marks.
Evidence is information, facts and figures, or examples that help support your argument. Evidence takes many different forms. It may be information, such as details about a place or event; facts and figures, such as statements or statistics about a place or event; or examples that illustrate what you are describing. Below are some examples of these three types of evidence:
1. Information
Hurricane Katrina was a powerful tropical storm that struck the southern coast of the United States.
2. Facts
There were 1,833 deaths as a result of Hurricane Katrina.
3. Examples
The impact of Hurricane Katrina could have been reduced if emergency plans had been practised before hurricanes occur, such as FEMA, which helps coordinate disaster search and rescue teams.
Although evidence can be used in different ways, the key is to ensure your evidence is specific to the place or event you are discussing. In the examples above, the text in bold shows the information specific to Hurricane Katrina. If this information were removed, the sentences would be more generic.
The easiest way to identify generic statements is to replace the event with another one. For example:
1. A) There were deaths as a result of Hurricane Katrina.
B) There were deaths as a result of Typhoon Haiyan.
2. A) The impact of Hurricane Katrina could have been reduced if they practised emergency plans before hurricanes occurred.
B) The impact of Typhoon Haiyan could have been reduced if they practised emergency plans before hurricanes occurred.
As you can see, by removing specific information and changing the event, the statement becomes generic and can be applied to many different events. This is not what the examiner is looking for.
Evidence is essential in the essay-style questions on your exam. So, how can we maximise the use of evidence throughout our answers?
When examiners are marking essay-style questions in your exam, they refer to a set of level descriptors, which require the examiner to place your answer into a level depending on how well it matches the criteria. The number of levels is determined by the number of marks available for the question. Once the examiner has identified the level your answer fits into, they then determine the marks you receive within that level.
The table below describes the criteria for a Level 3 or a Level 4 answer (depending on the highest level available for the corresponding question) in relation to evidence. These examples are taken from AQA past papers, but Edexcel uses similar criteria, although the wording may differ.
Qualification | Exam Board | Marks and Highest Level Available | Criteria |
GCSE | AQA | 9 marks Level 3 | … with good use of exemplification |
A level | AQA | 20 marks Level 4 | Detailed, highly relevant and appropriate knowledge…of place(s)…used throughout |
In simple terms, the examiner is looking for evidence that is specific to the place or event you are discussing and is used throughout your answer. This means that if you are following a PEEL writing structure, your evidence is not confined to the 'evidence' part of your paragraph. Instead, specific evidence can be used throughout the 'explain' part of your paragraph as well. Following a writing structure does not mean you cannot use evidence elsewhere in your answer, nor does it mean you should restrict the amount of evidence you use. You should use lots of evidence throughout your answer to support your argument. If your answer is too generic, you may struggle to reach the highest level.
Making your point specific to a place or event is a key skill within geography. It requires you to understand your content well and be able to apply it to real-world events and places.
Below is an example of how we might use evidence throughout a paragraph. This question is taken from an A level Edexcel past paper. This paragraph does not include the link back to the question that is required in the PEEL writing structure. It could also be expanded to discuss more links between GDP per capita and impacts. Don't worry if this looks daunting - you don't have to use all of this evidence, especially if you are taking GCSEs. Remember, this is just an example of how lots of evidence can be used! The text in bold shows where specific evidence has been used.
Question: Assess the reasons why some communities are more vulnerable than others to tectonic hazards (12 marks)
Example paragraph: Some communities are more vulnerable than others to tectonic hazards because of their GDP per capita. For example, Japan is a HIC and has a GDP per capita of $35,400, compared to Haiti, which is an LIC and has a GDP per capita of $3,080. GDP per capita is important because it determines the preparation that countries can put in place before a tectonic event occurs. The earthquake that occurred in Japan in 2011 caused 19,759 deaths, while the earthquake that occurred in Haiti in 2010 caused 220,000 deaths. Japan may have suffered fewer deaths due to its higher GDP per capita. A higher GDP per capita allowed Japan to build earthquake-resistant buildings which followed the Shin-Taishin building code. Earthquake-resistant buildings are expensive and require large amounts of investment. One way in which the Shin-Taishin building code helped to reduce the death toll in the 2011 Japan earthquake was that it required buildings to have flexible steel frames that could sway with seismic waves rather than snap under stress. This reduced the number of buildings that collapsed: 121,996 buildings collapsed. However, this number should be interpreted with caution, as it also includes the impact of the tsunami that followed. This means that fewer people will have suffered injuries and deaths from falling rubble. However, in Haiti, the low GDP per capita meant that investment in earthquake-resistant buildings was unaffordable. Therefore, 250,000 houses collapsed. Access to earthquake-resistant design may have also been limited by the country’s corruption (it scores 16 out of 100 on the Corruption Perceptions Index), meaning funds are not allocated to help local communities. The high number of homes collapsing may have led to a higher number of deaths than in Japan because of more falling rubble. Also, due to the low GDP per capita, there is a high population density in Haiti, as about 51% of the urban population lives in informal settlements, meaning there was more potential for a higher number of people to be injured.
With so much content to remember, there are also lots of examples and case studies to learn. Here are some tips to help you remember evidence:
1. Make sure you have clear examples and case studies for your content. For example, if you are revising earthquakes, make it clear which specific earthquakes you will talk about in an exam. Remember, for earthquakes, you should know one in an HIC and one in an LIC or NEE. For example, if I were revising earthquakes, I know that I will talk about Haiti (2010) as my LIC example and Japan (2011) as my HIC example.
2. Once you know which case studies you will talk about, think about what you need to know about them. For example, for earthquakes you may need to know the background information such as the causes, as well as the impacts and the responses. You don't need to remember every single detail about the case study. Instead, select a few key facts that you can apply and talk about easily and in detail in an exam.
3. You can use cross-curricular links. This means that one example you learn in one topic may be useful to use in another topic. For example, if you have learnt about California wildfires in your Hazards topic, why not apply some of this case study knowledge to your Water topic about the impacts of drought?
4. Keep up to date with the news! Your evidence doesn't have to come only from what you have learnt in class. You can include evidence you see or read in the news, or even facts you may learn whilst travelling or on holiday.
We can see that using evidence is essential to gaining higher marks in answers. It seems that this is where a lot of students struggle. One key barrier to including evidence in answers is that students struggle to remember details. This means that it is imperative to prioritise remembering specific details as much as learning your content. It could be the difference between grades!
Beth
Tutor
Qualified Geography Teacher – GCSE, IGCSE and A-Level Tutor
Sherpa has hundreds of qualified and experienced UK tutors who are ready to help you achieve your goals. Search through our tutors and arrange a free 20 minute introduction through our industry-leading online classroom.
Find a TutorSimilar Articles
My Child Knows the Answer. So Why Can’t They Write It?
Last week, I taught a student who spent more than two hours writing a single English Literature paragraph. Why is this?
Sundus
11th August 2026