GUEST POST
Umair is an AQA A-Level Psychology tutor specialising in exam technique, essay structure and tackling 16‑mark questions, with over three years’ tutoring experience. This article pinpoints why students lose marks on AQA 16‑mark Psychology essays and outlines practical fixes, including common mistakes to avoid, the PEL paragraph structure and effective exam-preparation strategies.
By Umair C | AQA A-Level Psychology Exam Technique Specialist | Sherpa Tutor
Why Students Lose Marks on AQA A-Level Psychology 16-Mark Essays (And How to Fix It)
One of the most common things I hear from A-Level Psychology students is: “I knew the content, so why didn't I get more marks?”
It's a fair question. You might have spent hours revising a topic, memorised the studies and learned several evaluation points, only to receive 9 or 10 marks out of 16.
So, where are those missing marks going?
From my experience tutoring A-Level Psychology, I've found that students often know considerably more than their exam answers demonstrate. The difficulty isn't always their understanding of Psychology. It's their ability to communicate that understanding in a way that meets the assessment objectives.
Knowing the content is important. Knowing how to turn that content into marks is equally important.
In this article, I'll explain why 16-mark essays deserve particular attention, the mistakes I regularly see students make, and the techniques you can use to improve your answers.
AQA A-Level Psychology is assessed through three examination papers, each worth 96 marks.
A single 16-mark question, therefore, represents one-sixth of the marks available on an individual paper.
To put this into perspective, imagine two students answering the same essay question.
Student A scores 10/16.
Student B scores 15/16.
That's a difference of five marks on a single question.
If similar differences occur across several extended-response questions, the overall impact can be significant.
This is why I encourage my students to practise essay writing throughout the course, rather than leaving it until the final few weeks before their examinations.
You can spend hours learning additional evaluation points, but if you haven't developed the skills to explain them effectively, you may continue losing the same marks.
One of the most common mistakes I see when marking students' essays is that students identify a valid evaluation point but do not explain it sufficiently.
Interestingly, this is something AQA examiners have highlighted too.
In the June 2023 A-Level Psychology Paper 2 Examiner Report, examiners distinguished between students who simply stated evaluative points and those who could explain strengths and limitations effectively.
The stronger responses demonstrated greater understanding through developed evaluation, rather than simply identifying relevant arguments.
Source: AQA June 2023 Paper 2 Examiner Report
This is exactly why I encourage students to focus on the quality of their evaluation paragraphs.
For example, consider this evaluation of Milgram's obedience research.
Weaker response:
"One limitation of Milgram's research is that it lacks ecological validity because it was conducted in a laboratory. This means the findings cannot be generalised to real life."
Although the student identifies a potential limitation, the argument is not sufficiently developed. Why might the laboratory environment be problematic? What does this mean for our understanding of obedience?
Stronger response:
"One limitation of Milgram's research is that the artificial laboratory setting may reduce its ecological validity. Participants were instructed to administer electric shocks in a controlled experimental environment, which differs from situations where individuals encounter authority figures in everyday life. Consequently, their behaviour may not accurately reflect obedience outside the laboratory, raising questions about the extent to which the findings explain obedience in real-world situations."
The second response develops the reasoning behind the criticism and explains its implications. The validity of this criticism can itself be debated, but it illustrates the importance of developing an argument.
My advice: After writing an evaluation point, ask yourself: "Have I explained why this matters?"
If you cannot answer that question, your paragraph probably needs further development.
Another issue I regularly encounter is students confusing the description of research with evaluation.
For example, when using a study to support a psychological explanation, students sometimes spend several sentences describing the procedure and findings without explaining how the evidence supports the explanation.
This distinction is important because AO1 and AO3 assess different skills.
AQA's June 2023 Paper 2 Examiner Report identified understanding as an important factor separating stronger and weaker responses. More successful students were able to use their knowledge flexibly and provide elaborated evaluation.
Source: AQA June 2023 Paper 2 Examiner Report
When writing AO3, your aim should not simply be to demonstrate that you remember a study.
You need to explain what the research tells us about the psychological explanation being evaluated.
For example, if you use research evidence to support the biological approach, don't stop after outlining the findings.
Explain how those findings support a biological explanation of behaviour and why this strengthens the approach.
My advice: Whenever you introduce research evidence in an evaluation paragraph, follow it with the question: "How does this evidence support or challenge the explanation?"
This helps turn descriptive knowledge into meaningful evaluation.
This is one of the most important mistakes students need to understand because AQA examiners have explicitly highlighted it in relation to 16-mark essays.
In the June 2022 Paper 1 Examiner Report, examiners discussed difficulties students experienced with the three 16-mark essays.
For the obedience question, students were expected to discuss what research into situational variables tells us about why people obey.
However, many students instead evaluated Milgram's research without clearly linking their discussion to the specific demands of the question.
Similar problems occurred in the attachment question, where students evaluated Lorenz's and Harlow's studies without sufficiently explaining what their findings tell us about human attachment.
Source: AQA June 2022 Paper 1 Examiner Report
This is a particularly useful lesson for students who rely heavily on memorised evaluation paragraphs.
An evaluation point can be psychologically accurate but still be poorly suited to the question you're answering.
For example, imagine you're asked to discuss what research into situational variables tells us about obedience.
You might remember that Milgram's original study has been criticised for ethical issues.
However, simply explaining that participants experienced psychological distress does not directly address what situational variables tell us about why people obey.
Unless you establish a relevant connection to the question, this discussion is unlikely to contribute much to your answer.
This is why I always encourage students to identify exactly what the question is asking before they begin writing.
My advice: Don't ask yourself only, "What evaluation points do I know?"
Instead, ask: "Which evaluation points actually help me answer this question?"
That distinction is essential.
A common misconception among students is that writing more evaluation paragraphs automatically produces a higher mark.
I've seen students attempt to include five or six evaluation points in a 16-mark essay, only to leave each argument underdeveloped.
However, AQA's level-based mark schemes assess the overall quality of the response, rather than awarding a fixed number of marks for each evaluation paragraph.
The importance of development is also reflected in AQA's examiner commentary.
In the June 2023 Paper 2 Examiner Report, examiners emphasised that stronger responses explained their evaluative arguments, while weaker responses tended to state points without sufficient elaboration.
Source: AQA June 2023 Paper 2 Examiner Report
This is why I teach students to focus on developing a smaller selection of relevant arguments rather than attempting to memorise as many evaluation points as possible.
For many 16-mark essays, three well-developed AO3 paragraphs can provide a useful structure, although this is not an official AQA requirement.
Your evaluation must still demonstrate sufficient breadth, depth, and relevance to the question.
My advice: Focus on whether each paragraph makes a clear, well-supported argument rather than simply counting how many paragraphs you've written.
One technique I teach students is the PEL structure.
PEL stands for Point, Evidence/Explanation, and Link.
It's a simple framework that helps students organise their evaluation and avoid writing paragraphs that are purely descriptive.
Begin with a clear evaluative argument.
For example:
“One strength of the behavioural approach is that it has practical applications in treating phobias.”
This immediately establishes what you're evaluating.
Next, support and develop your argument.
I recommend a two-step approach:
1. Why/How?
Explain the theory or evidence.
2. So why is that good or bad?
Explain why it strengthens or weakens the theory.
For example:
Behaviourists rejected subjective methods such as introspection and instead focused on studying observable behaviour under highly controlled laboratory conditions. For example, Skinner investigated operant conditioning using the Skinner box, where variables could be carefully controlled and behaviour could be objectively measured. This allowed researchers to establish clear cause-and-effect relationships between environmental stimuli and behaviour, making the findings more reliable and easier for other researchers to replicate. This is a strength because scientific methods produce objective evidence, increasing confidence that the conclusions drawn are accurate.
Finally, explain why your argument matters.
Two-step approach:
Therefore, it can be said that/may be argued that ...
1. Critical phrase that relates to the question
then
2. Because (give a reason)
For example:
Therefore, this demonstrates the value of the behaviourist approach because its use of scientific methods has helped psychology gain greater scientific credibility.
Remember that PEL is a writing tool, not an official marking formula. AQA examiners assess the quality of your response, rather than whether you have followed a particular acronym.
If you consistently lose marks on AO3, writing full essays repeatedly may not be the most efficient way to improve.
Instead, isolate the skill you're struggling with.
Choose an evaluation point and practise developing it into a complete paragraph.
Once you can consistently produce clear and well-developed evaluation, begin incorporating those paragraphs into timed essays.
AQA publishes mark schemes and examiner reports for past examination series.
These are particularly useful because they help you understand not just what content is relevant, but how students have approached questions and where their responses have fallen short.
When reviewing an essay, compare your answer against the level descriptors and read the examiner commentary where available.
You can access official materials through the AQA A-Level Psychology Specification and Assessment Resources.
If you receive 10/16 on an essay, don't simply write down the mark and move on.
Try to identify the reason your answer didn't reach the higher mark bands.
Was your AO1 inaccurate or lacking detail? Did you include evaluation points without developing them? Did your arguments drift away from the question?
Understanding why you lost marks is far more useful than simply knowing how many you lost.
When working with students, I find that identifying recurring weaknesses and practising those specific skills can be much more productive than repeatedly revising content they already understand.
My focus is helping students understand not just what to write in their Psychology exams, but how to write answers that meet examiner expectations. Through structured essay guidance, evaluation techniques, and past-paper walkthroughs, I aim to help students approach their exams with greater understanding and confidence.
Umair C
Tutor
Expert Psychology Tutor with proven A* results (AQA).
Sherpa has hundreds of qualified and experienced UK tutors who are ready to help you achieve your goals. Search through our tutors and arrange a free 20 minute introduction through our industry-leading online classroom.
Find a TutorSimilar Articles
How Did Students Revise During the Spring Holiday?
Discover how students and parents in key exam years used online tuition, revision and incentives to prepare for exams over the Spring-time school break.
Russell Kilgour
28th May 2025