Question 4: Evaluation Practice Questions

Question 1

hard

Source: 20th-century prose fiction
The Garden Party by Katherine Mansfield
An extract from the middle of a short story, published in 1922

It is the morning of a garden party at the Sheridan family’s large house, and workmen are putting up a marquee (a big party tent) in the garden. Laura and Jose are sisters, and Laura has just finished writing out the little labels for the party sandwiches. Sadie, Hans and the cook are the family’s servants, and Godber’s is the shop that is delivering cakes for the party.

1They were finished at last, and Laura took them off to the kitchen. She
found Jose there pacifying the cook, who did not look at all terrifying.
“I have never seen such exquisite sandwiches,” said Jose’s rapturous
voice. “How many kinds did you say there were, cook? Fifteen?”
5“Fifteen, Miss Jose.”
“Well, cook, I congratulate you.”
Cook swept up crusts with the long sandwich knife, and smiled broadly.
“Godber’s has come,” announced Sadie, issuing out of the pantry. She had
seen the man pass the window.
10That meant the cream puffs had come. Godber’s were famous for their
cream puffs. Nobody ever thought of making them at home.
“Bring them in and put them on the table, my girl,” ordered cook.
Sadie brought them in and went back to the door. Of course Laura and
Jose were far too grown-up to really care about such things. All the
15same, they couldn’t help agreeing that the puffs looked very attractive.
Very. Cook began arranging them, shaking off the extra icing sugar.
“Don’t they carry one back to all one’s parties?” said Laura.
“I suppose they do,” said practical Jose, who never liked to be carried
back. “They look beautifully light and feathery, I must say.”
20“Have one each, my dears,” said cook in her comfortable voice. “Yer ma
won’t know.”
Oh, impossible. Fancy cream puffs so soon after breakfast. The very idea
made one shudder. All the same, two minutes later Jose and Laura were
licking their fingers with that absorbed inward look that only comes
25from whipped cream.
“Let’s go into the garden, out by the back way,” suggested Laura. “I
want to see how the men are getting on with the marquee. They’re such
awfully nice men.”
But the back door was blocked by cook, Sadie, Godber’s man and Hans.
30Something had happened.
“Tuk-tuk-tuk,” clucked cook like an agitated hen. Sadie had her hand
clapped to her cheek as though she had toothache. Hans’s face was
screwed up in the effort to understand. Only Godber’s man seemed to be
enjoying himself; it was his story.
35“What’s the matter? What’s happened?”
“There’s been a horrible accident,” said Cook. “A man killed.”
“A man killed! Where? How? When?”
But Godber’s man wasn’t going to have his story snatched from under his
very nose.
40“Know those little cottages just below here, miss?” Know them? Of
course, she knew them. “Well, there’s a young chap living there, name of
Scott, a carter. His horse shied at a traction-engine, corner of Hawke
Street this morning, and he was thrown out on the back of his head.
Killed.”
45“Dead!” Laura stared at Godber’s man.
“Dead when they picked him up,” said Godber’s man with relish. “They
were taking the body home as I come up here.” And he said to the cook,
“He’s left a wife and five little ones.”
“Jose, come here.” Laura caught hold of her sister’s sleeve and dragged
50her through the kitchen to the other side of the green baize door. There
she paused and leaned against it. “Jose!” she said, horrified, “however
are we going to stop everything?”
“Stop everything, Laura!” cried Jose in astonishment. “What do you
mean?”
55“Stop the garden-party, of course.” Why did Jose pretend?
But Jose was still more amazed. “Stop the garden-party? My dear Laura,
don’t be so absurd. Of course we can’t do anything of the kind. Nobody
expects us to. Don’t be so extravagant.”
“But we can’t possibly have a garden-party with a man dead just outside
60the front gate.”
That really was extravagant, for the little cottages were in a lane to
themselves at the very bottom of a steep rise that led up to the house.
A broad road ran between. True, they were far too near. They were the
greatest possible eyesore, and they had no right to be in that
65neighbourhood at all. They were little mean dwellings painted a
chocolate brown. In the garden patches there was nothing but cabbage
stalks, sick hens and tomato cans. The very smoke coming out of their
chimneys was poverty-stricken. Little rags and shreds of smoke, so
unlike the great silvery plumes that uncurled from the Sheridans’
70chimneys. Washerwomen lived in the lane and sweeps and a cobbler, and a
man whose house-front was studded all over with minute bird-cages.
Children swarmed. When the Sheridans were little they were forbidden to
set foot there because of the revolting language and of what they might
catch. But since they were grown up, Laura and Laurie on their prowls
75sometimes walked through. It was disgusting and sordid. They came out
with a shudder. But still one must go everywhere; one must see
everything. So through they went.
“And just think of what the band would sound like to that poor woman,”
said Laura.
80“Oh, Laura!” Jose began to be seriously annoyed. “If you’re going to
stop a band playing every time some one has an accident, you’ll lead a
very strenuous life. I’m every bit as sorry about it as you. I feel just
as sympathetic.” Her eyes hardened. She looked at her sister just as she
used to when they were little and fighting together. “You won’t bring a
85drunken workman back to life by being sentimental,” she said softly.
“Drunk! Who said he was drunk?” Laura turned furiously on Jose. She
said, just as they had used to say on those occasions, “I’m going
straight up to tell mother.”
“Do, dear,” cooed Jose.

For this question focus on the second part of the source, from line 13 to the end.

In this part of the source, where the sisters eat cream puffs and then hear about the accident, the writer presents the household as comfortable and carefree. When the news comes, though, only Laura seems truly shaken by it.

To what extent do you agree and/or disagree with this statement?

In your response, you could:

  • consider your impressions of the household and their reactions to the news
  • comment on the methods the writer uses to present the household
  • support your response with references to the text.

[20 marks]

Total for Question 1 is 20 marks

Sign up free to see all 2 hard questions

Every question and mark scheme on this topic, with your marks saved as you go.

Question 2

hard

Source: 20th-century prose fiction
The Open Window by Saki
An extract from the end of a short story, published in 1914

Framton Nuttel, a nervous man, has come to stay in the countryside to rest his nerves. He is a stranger there and is calling on Mrs Sappleton, a lady he has never met, so he knows nothing about her or her family. While he waits for her to come downstairs, her fifteen-year-old niece points to a large French window, left wide open on an October afternoon, and tells him about a tragedy in her aunt’s life; Framton has only the niece’s word for it.

1“Out through that window, three years ago to a day, her husband and her
two young brothers went off for their day’s shooting. They never came
back. In crossing the moor to their favourite snipe-shooting ground they
were all three engulfed in a treacherous piece of bog. It had been that
5dreadful wet summer, you know, and places that were safe in other years
gave way suddenly without warning. Their bodies were never recovered.
That was the dreadful part of it.” Here the child’s voice lost its
self-possessed note and became falteringly human. “Poor aunt always
thinks that they will come back some day, they and the little brown
10spaniel that was lost with them, and walk in at that window just as they
used to do. That is why the window is kept open every evening till it is
quite dusk. Poor dear aunt, she has often told me how they went out, her
husband with his white waterproof coat over his arm, and Ronnie, her
youngest brother, singing ‘Bertie, why do you bound?’ as he always did
15to tease her, because she said it got on her nerves. Do you know,
sometimes on still, quiet evenings like this, I almost get a creepy
feeling that they will all walk in through that window—”
She broke off with a little shudder. It was a relief to Framton when the
aunt bustled into the room with a whirl of apologies for being late in
20making her appearance.
“I hope Vera has been amusing you?” she said.
“She has been very interesting,” said Framton.
“I hope you don’t mind the open window,” said Mrs. Sappleton briskly;
“my husband and brothers will be home directly from shooting, and they
25always come in this way. They’ve been out for snipe in the marshes
to-day, so they’ll make a fine mess over my poor carpets. So like you
men-folk, isn’t it?”
She rattled on cheerfully about the shooting and the scarcity of birds,
and the prospects for duck in the winter. To Framton it was all purely
30horrible. He made a desperate but only partially successful effort to
turn the talk on to a less ghastly topic; he was conscious that his
hostess was giving him only a fragment of her attention, and her eyes
were constantly straying past him to the open window and the lawn
beyond. It was certainly an unfortunate coincidence that he should have
35paid his visit on this tragic anniversary.
“The doctors agree in ordering me complete rest, an absence of mental
excitement, and avoidance of anything in the nature of violent physical
exercise,” announced Framton, who laboured under the tolerably
widespread delusion that total strangers and chance acquaintances are
40hungry for the least detail of one’s ailments and infirmities, their
cause and cure. “On the matter of diet they are not so much in
agreement,” he continued.
“No?” said Mrs. Sappleton, in a voice which only replaced a yawn at the
last moment. Then she suddenly brightened into alert attention—but not
45to what Framton was saying.
“Here they are at last!” she cried. “Just in time for tea, and don’t
they look as if they were muddy up to the eyes!”
Framton shivered slightly and turned towards the niece with a look
intended to convey sympathetic comprehension. The child was staring out
50through the open window with dazed horror in her eyes. In a chill shock
of nameless fear Framton swung round in his seat and looked in the same
direction.
In the deepening twilight three figures were walking across the lawn
towards the window; they all carried guns under their arms, and one of
55them was additionally burdened with a white coat hung over his
shoulders. A tired brown spaniel kept close at their heels. Noiselessly
they neared the house, and then a hoarse young voice chanted out of the
dusk: “I said, Bertie, why do you bound?”
Framton grabbed wildly at his stick and hat; the hall-door, the
60gravel-drive, and the front gate were dimly-noted stages in his headlong
retreat. A cyclist coming along the road had to run into the hedge to
avoid an imminent collision.
“Here we are, my dear,” said the bearer of the white mackintosh, coming
in through the window; “fairly muddy, but most of it’s dry. Who was that
65who bolted out as we came up?”
“A most extraordinary man, a Mr. Nuttel,” said Mrs. Sappleton; “could
only talk about his illnesses, and dashed off without a word of good-bye
or apology when you arrived. One would think he had seen a ghost.”
“I expect it was the spaniel,” said the niece calmly; “he told me he had
70a horror of dogs. He was once hunted into a cemetery somewhere on the
banks of the Ganges by a pack of pariah dogs, and had to spend the night
in a newly dug grave with the creatures snarling and grinning and
foaming just above him. Enough to make anyone lose their nerve.”
Romance at short notice was her speciality.

For this question focus on the second part of the source, from line 28 to the end.

In this part of the source, where Framton sits with Mrs Sappleton until three figures appear on the lawn, the writer presents Framton as a figure of fun rather than someone to feel sorry for. The niece seems cruel rather than clever.

To what extent do you agree and/or disagree with this statement?

In your response, you could:

  • consider your impressions of Framton and the niece
  • comment on the methods the writer uses to present them
  • support your response with references to the text.

[20 marks]

Total for Question 2 is 20 marks