Question 4: Comparing Viewpoints Practice Questions

Question 1

hard

Source A: 20th-century literary non-fiction
The People of the Abyss by Jack London
An extract from a book, published in 1903

In 1902 the American writer Jack London spent several weeks in London dressed as a penniless man, so that he could report on the lives of the very poor. In this chapter he walks the streets of the West End through one wet night, and has just watched an old homeless woman being moved on by one policeman after another. To "carry the banner" is slang for walking the streets all night, and a "bobby" is a policeman.

1Now, said I, at one o’clock, to myself; consider that you are a poor
young man, penniless, in London Town, and that to-morrow you must look
for work. It is necessary, therefore, that you get some sleep in order
that you may have strength to look for work and to do work in case you
5find it.
So I sat down on the stone steps of a building. Five minutes later a
policeman was looking at me. My eyes were wide open, so he only grunted
and passed on. Ten minutes later my head was on my knees, I was dozing,
and the same policeman was saying gruffly, “’Ere, you, get outa that!”
10I got. And, like the old woman, I continued to get; for every time I
dozed, a policeman was there to rout me along again. Not long after,
when I had given this up, I was walking with a young Londoner (who had
been out to the colonies and wished he were out to them again), when I
noticed an open passage leading under a building and disappearing in
15darkness. A low iron gate barred the entrance.
“Come on,” I said. “Let’s climb over and get a good sleep.”
“Wot?” he answered, recoiling from me. “An’ get run in fer three months!
Blimey if I do!”
Later on I was passing Hyde Park with a young boy of fourteen or
20fifteen, a most wretched-looking youth, gaunt and hollow-eyed and sick.
“Let’s go over the fence,” I proposed, “and crawl into the shrubbery for
a sleep. The bobbies couldn’t find us there.”
“No fear,” he answered. “There’s the park guardians, and they’d run you
in for six months.”
25Times have changed, alas! When I was a youngster I used to read of
homeless boys sleeping in doorways. Already the thing has become a
tradition. As a stock situation it will doubtless linger in literature
for a century to come, but as a cold fact it has ceased to be. Here are
the doorways, and here are the boys, but happy conjunctions are no
30longer effected. The doorways remain empty, and the boys keep awake and
carry the banner.
“I was down under the arches,” grumbled another young fellow. By
“arches” he meant the shore arches where begin the bridges that span the
Thames. “I was down under the arches wen it was ryning its ’ardest, an’
35a bobby comes in an’ chyses me out. But I come back, an’ ’e come too.
‘’Ere,’ sez ’e, ‘wot you doin’ ’ere?’ An’ out I goes, but I sez, ‘Think
I want ter pinch [steal] the bleedin’ bridge?’”
Among those who carry the banner, Green Park has the reputation of
opening its gates earlier than the other parks, and at quarter-past four
40in the morning, I, and many more, entered Green Park. It was raining
again, but they were worn out with the night’s walking, and they were
down on the benches and asleep at once. Many of the men stretched out
full length on the dripping wet grass, and, with the rain falling
steadily upon them, were sleeping the sleep of exhaustion.
45And now I wish to criticise the powers that be. They are the powers,
therefore they may decree whatever they please; so I make bold only to
criticise the ridiculousness of their decrees. All night long they make
the homeless ones walk up and down. They drive them out of doors and
passages, and lock them out of the parks. The evident intention of all
50this is to deprive them of sleep. Well and good, the powers have the
power to deprive them of sleep, or of anything else for that matter; but
why under the sun do they open the gates of the parks at five o’clock in
the morning and let the homeless ones go inside and sleep? If it is
their intention to deprive them of sleep, why do they let them sleep
55after five in the morning? And if it is not their intention to deprive
them of sleep, why don’t they let them sleep earlier in the night?
In this connection, I will say that I came by Green Park that same day,
at one in the afternoon, and that I counted scores of the ragged
wretches asleep in the grass. It was Sunday afternoon, the sun was
60fitfully appearing, and the well-dressed West Enders, with their wives
and progeny, were out by thousands, taking the air. It was not a
pleasant sight for them, those horrible, unkempt, sleeping vagabonds;
while the vagabonds themselves, I know, would rather have done their
sleeping the night before.
65And so, dear soft people, should you ever visit London Town, and see
these men asleep on the benches and in the grass, please do not think
they are lazy creatures, preferring sleep to work. Know that the powers
that be have kept them walking all the night long, and that in the day
they have nowhere else to sleep.

Source B: 19th-century literary non-fiction
Night Walks by Charles Dickens
An extract from a magazine essay, published in 1860

The novelist Charles Dickens wrote this essay about a time, some years earlier, when he could not sleep and walked the streets of London all through the night. He calls himself and the homeless people he meets "houseless", and sometimes calls himself "Houselessness". At the time, people paid a small toll (a halfpenny) to a toll-keeper to cross Waterloo Bridge.

1Some years ago, a temporary inability to sleep, referable to a
distressing impression, caused me to walk about the streets all night,
for a series of several nights. The disorder might have taken a long
time to conquer, if it had been faintly experimented on in bed; but, it
5was soon defeated by the brisk treatment of getting up directly after
lying down, and going out, and coming home tired at sunrise.
In the course of those nights, I finished my education in a fair amateur
experience of houselessness. My principal object being to get through
the night, the pursuit of it brought me into sympathetic relations with
10people who have no other object every night in the year.
The month was March, and the weather damp, cloudy, and cold. The sun not
rising before half-past five, the night perspective looked sufficiently
long at half-past twelve: which was about my time for confronting it.
The restlessness of a great city, and the way in which it tumbles and
15tosses before it can get to sleep, formed one of the first
entertainments offered to the contemplation of us houseless people. It
lasted about two hours. We lost a great deal of companionship when the
late public-houses turned their lamps out, and when the potmen thrust
the last brawling drunkards into the street; but stray vehicles and
20stray people were left us, after that. If we were very lucky, a
policeman’s rattle sprang and a fray turned up; but, in general,
surprisingly little of this diversion was provided. Except in the
Haymarket, which is the worst kept part of London, and about Kent-street
in the Borough, and along a portion of the line of the Old Kent-road,
25the peace was seldom violently broken. But, it was always the case that
London, as if in imitation of individual citizens belonging to it, had
expiring fits and starts of restlessness. After all seemed quiet, if one
cab rattled by, half-a-dozen would surely follow; and Houselessness even
observed that intoxicated people appeared to be magnetically attracted
30towards each other; so that we knew when we saw one drunken object
staggering against the shutters of a shop, that another drunken object
would stagger up before five minutes were out, to fraternise or fight
with it. When we made a divergence from the regular species of drunkard,
the thin-armed, puff-faced, leaden-lipped gin-drinker, and encountered a
35rarer specimen of a more decent appearance, fifty to one but that
specimen was dressed in soiled mourning. As the street experience in the
night, so the street experience in the day; the common folk who come
unexpectedly into a little property, come unexpectedly into a deal of
liquor.
40At length these flickering sparks would die away, worn out—the last
veritable sparks of waking life trailed from some late pieman or
hot-potato man—and London would sink to rest. And then the yearning of
the houseless mind would be for any sign of company, any lighted place,
any movement, anything suggestive of any one being up—nay, even so much
45as awake, for the houseless eye looked out for lights in windows.
Walking the streets under the pattering rain, Houselessness would walk
and walk and walk, seeing nothing but the interminable tangle of
streets, save at a corner, here and there, two policemen in
conversation, or the sergeant or inspector looking after his men. Now
50and then in the night—but rarely—Houselessness would become aware of a
furtive head peering out of a doorway a few yards before him, and,
coming up with the head, would find a man standing bolt upright to keep
within the doorway’s shadow, and evidently intent upon no particular
service to society. Under a kind of fascination, and in a ghostly
55silence suitable to the time, Houselessness and this gentleman would eye
one another from head to foot, and so, without exchange of speech, part,
mutually suspicious. Drip, drip, drip, from ledge and coping, splash
from pipes and water-spouts, and by-and-by the houseless shadow would
fall upon the stones that pave the way to Waterloo-bridge; it being in
60the houseless mind to have a halfpenny worth of excuse for saying
‘Good-night’ to the toll-keeper, and catching a glimpse of his fire. A
good fire and a good great-coat and a good woollen neck-shawl, were
comfortable things to see in conjunction with the toll-keeper; also his
brisk wakefulness was excellent company when he rattled the change of
65halfpence down upon that metal table of his, like a man who defied the
night, with all its sorrowful thoughts, and didn’t care for the coming
of dawn.

For this question, you need to refer to the whole of Source A, together with the whole of Source B.

Compare how the writers convey their different attitudes to spending the night on the streets of London.

In your answer, you could:

  • compare their different attitudes
  • comment on the methods the writers use to convey their different attitudes
  • support your response with references to both texts.

[16 marks]

Total for Question 1 is 16 marks

Sign up free to see all 2 hard questions

Every question and mark scheme on this topic, with your marks saved as you go.

Question 2

hard

Source A: 20th-century non-fiction
Freedom or Death by Emmeline Pankhurst
An extract from a speech given in Hartford, Connecticut, USA, in 1913

In 1913 the British campaigner Emmeline Pankhurst toured the United States to raise support and money for the fight to win British women the vote ("suffrage"). Her followers, the suffragettes, broke windows and damaged property to force the government to act, and many who were sent to prison went on "hunger strike", refusing all food until the authorities had to let them out. In this part of her speech she tells her American audience how the government responded; the "home secretary" is the minister in charge of prisons.

1Now, that went on so long that the government felt they had lost their
power, and that they were unable to cope with the situation. Then it was
that, to the shame of the British government, they set the example to
authorities all over the world of feeding sane, resisting human beings
5by force. There may be doctors in this meeting: if so, they know it is
one thing to treat an insane person, to feed by force an insane person,
or a patient who has some form of illness which makes it necessary; but
it is quite another thing to feed a sane, resisting human being who
resists with every nerve and with every fibre of her body the indignity
10and the outrage of forcible feeding. Now, that was done in England, and
the government thought they had crushed us. But they found that it did
not quell the agitation, that more and more women came in and even
passed that terrible ordeal, and that they were not able with all their
forcible feeding to make women serve out their unjust sentences. They
15were obliged to let them go.
Then came the legislation to which I have referred, the legislation
which is known in England as the “Cat and Mouse Act”. It got through the
British House of Commons because the home secretary assured the House of
Commons that he wanted the bill passed in the interests of humanity. He
20said he was a humane man and he did not like having to resort to
forcible feeding; he wanted the House of Commons to give him some way of
disposing of them, and this was his way: he said, “Give me the power to
let these women go when they are at death’s door, and leave them at
liberty under license until they have recovered their health again and
25then bring them back; leave it to me to fix the time of their licenses:
leave it in my hands altogether to deal with this intolerable situation,
because the laws must be obeyed and people who are sentenced for
breaking the law must be compelled to serve their sentences.” Well, the
House of Commons passed the law. They said: “As soon as the women get a
30taste of this they will give it up.” In fact, it was passed to repress
the agitation, to make the women yield—because that is what it has
really come to, ladies and gentlemen. It has come to a battle between
the women and the government as to who shall yield first, whether they
will yield and give us the vote, or whether we will give up our
35agitation.
Well, they little know what women are. Women are very slow to rouse, but
once they are aroused, once they are determined, nothing on earth and
nothing in heaven will make women give way; it is impossible. And so
this “Cat and Mouse Act” which is being used against women today has
40failed: and the home secretary has taken advantage of the fact that
parliament is not sitting, to revive and use alongside of it the
forcible feeding. At the present time there are women lying at death’s
door, recovering enough strength to undergo operations, who have had
both systems applied to them, and have not given in and won’t give in,
45and who will be prepared, as soon as they get up from their sick beds,
to go on as before. There are women who are being carried from their
sick beds on stretchers into meetings. They are too weak to speak, but
they go amongst their fellow workers just to show that their spirits are
unquenched, and that their spirit is alive, and they mean to go on as
50long as life lasts.
Now, I want to say to you who think women cannot succeed, we have
brought the government of England to this position, that it has to face
this alternative: either women are to be killed or women are to have the
vote. I ask American men in this meeting, what would you say if in your
55state you were faced with that alternative, that you must either kill
them or give them their citizenship—women, many of whom you respect,
women whom you know have lived useful lives, women whom you know, even
if you do not know them personally, are animated with the highest
motives, women who are in pursuit of liberty and the power to do useful
60public service? Well, there is only one answer to that alternative;
there is only one way out of it, unless you are prepared to put back
civilisation two or three generations: you must give those women the
vote. Now that is the outcome of our civil war.

Source B: 19th-century non-fiction
Female Suffrage by Goldwin Smith
An extract from an essay, published as a pamphlet in 1875

In 1874, while Parliament was debating a bill to give some women the vote, the historian Goldwin Smith wrote a magazine essay arguing against it, and it was reprinted as a pamphlet the following year. "Mitigate" means make less severe, and "party politics" is the contest between political parties; the Reign of Terror (1793–94) and the Commune (1871) were violent times of revolution in France. The "most eminent" supporter of votes for women whom he mentions is the philosopher John Stuart Mill.

1It is alleged that female influence would mitigate the violence of party
politics. But what ground have we, in reason or experience, for
believing that women, if introduced into the political arena, would be
less violent than men? Hitherto they have been free from political
5vices, because they have generally taken no part in politics, just as
home has been an asylum from political rancour because political
division has not been introduced between man and wife. But the chances
are that, being more excitable, and having, with more warmth and
generosity of temperament, less power of self-control, women would, when
10once engaged in party struggles, be not less, but more violent than men.
All our experience, in fact, points this way. In the reign of Terror,
and in the revolt of the Commune, the women notoriously rivalled the men
in fury and ferocity. The same was the case in the late American Civil
War. What has been the effect of public life on the character of the
15women who have thrown themselves into it in the United States can be
doubted by no human being; and our experience of female agitations in
this country seems to tell pretty much the same tale. That party
politics require mitigation, and perhaps something more, may be readily
admitted; but we are not likely to make the cauldron boil less fiercely
20by flinging into it female character and Home.
That Home would escape disturbance it is surely difficult to believe. We
are told that a difference of religion between man and wife does not
produce unhappiness. The fact may be doubted when the difference is
strong. But religion is an affair of the other world; and it does not,
25at all events it need not, bring people into direct, much less into
public collision in this world. A man and his wife taking opposite sides
in politics would be brought into direct and public collision,
especially if they happened to be active politicians, about a subject of
the most exciting kind. Would the harmony of most households bear the
30strain? Would not a husband who cared for his own happiness be apt to
say that if his wife wanted it she might have the vote, but that there
should be only one vote between them? The most eminent of the living
advocates of Female Suffrage suggests that in future agreement in
politics will be one of the conditions of marriage; which at all events
35proves that in his opinion disagreement in politics, if both husband and
wife were politicians, would endanger the harmony of married life.
Men are not good housekeepers, and there need not be anything
disparaging in saying that women, as a rule, are not likely to be good
politicians. Most of them, after all, will be married, and their sphere
40will be one in which they do not directly feel the effects of good or
bad government, which are directly felt by the man who goes forth to
labour, and the practical sense of which, more than anything else, forms
the political wisdom, such as it is, of the great mass of mankind.

For this question, you need to refer to the whole of Source A, together with the whole of Source B.

Compare how the writers convey their different attitudes to women winning the right to vote.

In your answer, you could:

  • compare their different attitudes
  • comment on the methods the writers use to convey their different attitudes
  • support your response with references to both texts.

[16 marks]

Total for Question 2 is 16 marks